June 14, 2021

George Cafe Journal

The Power of Success

AMC Stock Analysts: These Meme Stocks Are 90% Overvalued

Good luck telling investors there’s 90% downside in AMC stock — which made them a fortune compared to the S&P 500’s gain. But that’s analysts’ task when covering so-called meme stocks.


Analysts think the major stocks being pushed up in online forums, namely the ringleaders AMC Entertainment (AMC), GameStop (GME) and BlackBerry (BB), are all grossly overvalued, says an Investor’s Business Daily analysis of data from S&P Global Market Intelligence and MarketSmith.

AMC Not Alone In Analysts’ Sights

Dim analyst outlooks on these stocks aren’t a surprise. Investors talking up stocks on online forums like Reddit focus on companies they have affinity for. Many are left for dead, or shorted by larger investors. But analysts’ warnings are so dire, it’s prudent to pay attention.

“Rallies like AMC, GME, show that retail investors are looking for opportunities in the stock market,” said Hossein Azari, CEO of market data analysis firm, cmorq. They “are willing to take risks, and more importantly have the power and capital to really move the market.”

Meme Darling AMC Stock: 90% Downside?

AMC stock analysts couldn’t be much more bearish on the stock. But don’t try telling that to AMC stock owners.

Shares of the struggling movie chain are up 2,323% this year. That’s a larger gain than just about any other major stock. Amazingly, the stock has nudged beleaguered game seller GameStop aside as the lead actor in the meme stock phenomenon. AMC is also making billions for its top investors and executives.

But the seven analysts still covering the stock are essentially saying it’s curtains for AMC. Analysts hold an average 12-month price target on the stock, now more valuable than about half the S&P 500, of just 5.11 a share. That’s a staggering 90% implied downside from AMC stock’s 51.34 closing price on Thursday.

And that masks some even more negative targets. Influential analyst David Trainer of New Constructs thinks the stock is worthless. AMC still owes more than $5 billion in long-term debt.

Investors got a taste of selling Thursday. AMC stock fell 18% following another multi-million dollar stock offering.

Analysts also think the company will lose money in at least each of the next three years. Forecasts call for an adjusted loss of $1.4 billion this year, $428 million next year and $271 million in 2023.

90% Downside In GameStop?

GameStop lost its leading mojo a bit with meme-stock investors. The stock is also an example of how you can lose lots of money on these stocks. It’s down half from its all-time closing high of 483. And analysts still think the stock is living on borrowed time.

Analysts predict GameStop stock will only be worth 26 a share in 12 months. If that’s right, it would signal a nearly 90% drop from Thursday’s close of 258.18. And as with AMC, analysts are bearish on the fundamentals, too. GameStop is expected to lose another $46 million in the current fiscal year ending in January, after losing $139 million in the most recent year. And analysts see the company losing another $12 million in fiscal 2023.

And yet, shares of GameStop are up 59% in the past month. Normally, that would be an untouchable run. In a world where AMC stock is up 429% in a month, GameStop suddenly looks like it’s a supporting actor. But analysts are still warning downside looms.

Some Forecasts On Meme Aren’t As Onerous

Analysts aren’t quite as negative on all meme stocks — including some of the more recent stocks to join in.

Fallen mobile connectivity company, BlackBerry, is one of the newest playthings with meme investors. They’ve pushed the stock up nearly 140% this year to 15.88 a share. And yet, analysts think BlackBerry stock should only be worth about half that, 8, in 12 months.

Similarly, analysts are calling for 23% downside in Bed Bath & Beyond (BBBY), 19% downside in Beyond Meat (BYND) and 7% downside in Workhorse Group (WKHS).

To be sure, it can be profitable to stray from the establishment on stocks — and find true leaders like the ones on Leaderboard. The market also give you clues which stocks to own and when. Also, these stock rallies could turn into self-fulfilling prophesies if the companies raise more cash. Plus, analysts get plenty of calls wrong.

But given how dire the analysts’ outlooks are, it’s best to make sure you have sound investing rules. And make sure you know what to do if the crowd is wrong.

What Analysts Think Of Major Meme Stocks

12-month price targets signal downside

Company Symbol Thurs. close 12-month target price Stock YTD % ch. Implied downside % to target Sector
AMC Entertainment Holdings (AMC) 51.34 5.11 2,321.7% -90.1% Communication Services
GameStop (GME) 258.18 26.00 1,270.4% -89.9% Consumer Discretionary
Koss (KOSS) 30.83 n/a 796.2% n/a Consumer Discretionary
Express (EXPR) 5.24 4.08 475.8% -22.1% Consumer Discretionary
BlackBerry (BB) 15.88 8.00 139.5% -49.6% Information Technology
Bed Bath & Beyond (BBBY) 31.90 25.85 79.6% -19.0% Consumer Discretionary
Beyond Meat (BYND) 143.06 116.20 14.4% -18.8% Consumer Staples
Workhorse Group (WKHS) 14.77 13.70 -25.3% -7.2% Consumer Discretionary
Source: IBD, S&P Global Market Intelligence

Follow Matt Krantz on Twitter @mattkrantz


Bank of America Names Top 11 Stock Picks For 2021

8 Top Stocks Will Soar Again In 2021, Analysts Say

MarketSmith: Research, Charts, Data And Coaching All In One Place

These 12 Stocks Turned $10,000 To $257,833 In 12 Months

Five Stocks Flashing Buy Signals; Tesla Faces Key Test